Reader · no content
No body text on file.
Open the original to read the full piece.
Libby Schaaf Failed Oakland. She Just Got Promoted.
Brief
Libby Schaaf’s April 2026 appointment as CEO of the Bay Area Council places a former Oakland mayor with a contested record at the head of the region’s largest business lobby. Her eight-year tenure saw OPD staffing drop from over 800 to under 690 (about 515 officers on the street), producing 11.1 violent crimes per sworn officer versus a PFM‑recommended minimum of 877, and prompting a December 2021 request for state law‑enforcement help. Economically, the Howard Terminal stadium deal collapsed, the A’s left, thousands of businesses exited after a progressive business tax, and Oakland suffered bond/credit downgrades. Schaaf launched a March 2021 $500/month, 600‑family guaranteed‑income pilot that faced Equal Protection lawsuits and was broadened in April 2021. She settled Oakland ethics charges for $21,000 in October 2024, and her successor Sheng Thao was recalled by >60% and later federally indicted. The article frames the hire as “failing upward” and urges the Council to demand measurable outcomes on transit, housing, and business retention.
Why it matters
In April 2026 the Bay Area Council named former Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf its CEO; the Council represents thousands of companies across nine Bay Area counties.
Key details
- During Schaaf’s eight years as mayor Oakland Police Department staffing fell from over 800 officers to under 690, with roughly 515 officers actually working beats and 11.1 violent crimes per sworn officer; a PFM study estimated a minimum need of 877 sworn officers.
- Schaaf paid $21,000 in October 2024 to settle charges from the Oakland Public Ethics Commission over election-law violations, and her political machine’s successor, Sheng Thao, was recalled by over 60% of voters and later indicted on federal bribery charges facing up to 95 years in prison.
- Major economic and fiscal setbacks during Schaaf’s tenure included the collapse of the Howard Terminal stadium deal and the A’s exit, thousands of businesses leaving after a progressive business tax, and bond/credit rating downgrades for the city; her marquee policy was a March 2021 guaranteed-income pilot ($500/month to 600 families for 18 months) that faced legal challenges and was subsequently broadened.